Four decades after Josie Scott convinced her brother Kim to learn bass and start a band, The Mark of Cain are writing the next chapter of their story – even as they celebrate the 25th anniversary of their 2001 album This Is This.

The biblical story of the Mark of Cain is rarely cited as a model for healthy sibling dynamics. But for Josie and Mark Scott, family ties are still a driving force behind their on and off-stage partnership as the long-running hard rock outfit of the same name.
“At the outset of The Mark of Cain, I wasn’t particularly interested in being in a band – music was a secondary thing,” Kim Scott tells InReview.
It was Josie’s idea for Kim to learn bass and form a band, operating under the rationale that – aside from famous exceptions like the Gallaghers – family bands have greater staying power.
“They seem to find longevity because, you know, blood’s thicker than water, and you can get through some difficult days in a hot tin shed where you might not see eye to eye, but because you’re blood-related, you just move on.”
Four decades later, Josie’s logic has proved sound: after five furious studio albums and countless live shows around the world, the Scotts have been The Mark of Cain’s only consistent members.
This year the trio – rounded out by Adelaide drummer Eli Green who took over from American drummer John Stanier (Helmet, Battles) 12 years ago – have been back on the road to mark the anniversary of their 2001 album This Is This.
“As as you get older as a band, there’s always an anniversary,” Kim says of the band’s last tour, celebrating three decades of their Henry Rollins-produced 1995 album Ill at Ease. “So we came back from that one, and normally we would then go, ‘Okay, well that’s kind of touring done, let’s have a break and not do anything’.”
This time, however, they decided to channel the momentum into their first new material in over a decade, convening in a rehearsal room almost every week to work on new songs. It’s the catalyst for this latest tour, which will see the 2001 material played alongside the tracks they’ve workshopped with Green.
“We used to joke that [Eli’s] the intern or work experience student that’s been with us for 11 years now,” Scott says. “But as he’s said, it’s kind of like he did a PhD in The Mark of Cain; and he knows exactly what we sound like, how we write, what our structures are – and is an accomplished songwriter himself.
“So he’s actually been doing a lot of more of the writing and bringing completed songs. Josie’s also still writing – I mean, she’s always going to be the lyricist – but I think the benefit is she’s not feeling as much pressure. I think it’s just re-energised us to give us a fresh outlook.”
With Kim recently recovering from a major cycling injury – the latest in a long line of injuries that have seen him break his pelvis, collarbones and 26 ribs – the trio have been hard at work to recapture their famously precise and punishing live sound.
This latest tour was also preceded by Josie’s move to come out as trans in a post on the band’s social media in February.
“As I’ve aged, and mortality is ever closer, I’ve decided to embrace, rather than endure, who I am,” she wrote at the time.
Kim says there was a “bit of trepidation” before the band’s first show following the announcement.

“Josie understood that she was going to start looking differently, and didn’t want fans to show up to this next show and go, ‘What’s happened?’” he explains. “So [we] felt it was important to let our fans know what she was going through.”
Kim says most fans embraced the news, with many quickly returning to the default setting of asking about their next show, and whether they were working on new material.
“We’ve had a great fan base who are super supportive,” he says. “I’d say 98% are supportive – those 2% that we’ve lost, maybe we didn’t want them anyway.”
While Josie’s February post acknowledged that her years-long experience of gender dysphoria appeared as subtext in some of their older work, Kim echoes her broader point that the chief theme of the band remains unchanged.
“The loner theme has been a consistent theme of The Mark of Cain, and that’s how Josie and I felt going through high school. And the whole concept of the ‘Mark of Cain’ was not a physical mark, but a psychological mark that made you realise you weren’t going to fit in with society.
“You were always going to be different than everyone else, but enjoying being outside that inner circle and actually saying, ‘You know what, embrace it. It’s okay being different, it’s a good thing.
“The fact that it also was part of her journey and the secret that she was living with – and she said she left some breadcrumbs through some of the lyrics – but it doesn’t change the fact that that’s how we’ve always felt, you know?”

While Josie recruited Kim on bass to lock down her band’s long-term prospects, Kim reflects that it’s also made them closer over the four decades they’ve made and played music together.
“It’s been a great thing, because as siblings, we spend time on the road together, and then when we’re back in Adelaide, we still see each other,” he says.
“I think when she told me of gender dysphoria probably two-and-a-half, maybe three years ago now, it did take me by surprise – because I never realised that. But I quickly came to the realisation that she’s still the same person; it’s just a gender identity thing. It doesn’t change anything else about the person – so realistically, nothing has much changed other than huge respect for the fact that she’s now had the courage to live a more authentic life going forward.
“But musically, nothing’s changed, and I think people will see that in the songs that are coming out in this next couple of shows. That nothing’s changed.”
The Mark of Cain play Hindley Street Music Hall with Stabbitha and The Knifey Wifeys and Witch Spit on Saturday November 21
Want to see more stories from InDaily SA in your Google search results?
This article may be shared online or in print under a Creative Commons licence