Murders most foul – but can the reader decide who did it?

A veteran journalist and author explores a confounding case of a triple murder and asks readers to be the jury in this case.

Nov 18, 2026, updated Nov 17, 2026
In his latest book, veteran journalist and author Steve Bishop revisits a murder case that has intrigued him for decades.
In his latest book, veteran journalist and author Steve Bishop revisits a murder case that has intrigued him for decades.

Three cold-blooded murders in the red heart of the Australian Outback shocked the country and were front page news for nearly a month. But the resulting police investigation and court case were a multi-bungled fiasco.

And for nearly 70 years senior legal figures have held grave doubts about the conduct of the trial, which continues to have major repercussions.

As an investigative journalist, I have spent many years piecing together the facts and trying to have the resulting miscarriages of justice rectified. Now I’m challenging readers of my new book, The Sundown Murders Scandal: You Be the Jury, to do better than the real jury.

The book is not so much a whodunnit as a tangled “did-he-do-it”.

Three people were executed as they slept by the side of a dirt track near the abandoned Sundown Station while driving from Alice Springs to spend Christmas 1957 in Adelaide. Homesteaders in the vast isolated Outback were terrified there was a maniac on the loose.

Author Steve Bishop.

The weeks-long furore put the police under enormous pressure but, with as few as a dozen cars a day negotiating the pot-holed and corrugated track through hundreds of kilometres of semi-desert with only the occasional homestead every 80 kilometres or so, the killer had vanished.

It was a month before a flimsy tip-off led to a nationwide search for the driver of a black car towing a caravan.

In what was then the isolated frontier mining town of Mount Isa, hundreds of kilometres away in Queensland, ambitious young detective Glen Hallahan found the car and arrested Raymond Bailey, an itinerant carpenter who had been driving from town to town with his wife and their toddler to find work.

Subscribe for updates

Hallahan, Queensland’s youngest detective, interviewed Bailey and produced a confession which was then further developed by two Adelaide detectives along with a third version of the confession bearing Bailey’s signature. A disillusioned, booze-befuddled barrister, Arthur Pickering QC, was hired to defend Bailey at the Adelaide Supreme Court trial.

The evidence swung one way and then the other as witnesses testified and barristers battled. The judge told the jury Bailey’s “progressive admissions … were part of a willingness on his part perhaps to rid his conscience of guilt by confession, producing a statement by him about which you can have no doubt”.

But there was massive doubt – because the confessions bore no resemblance to the actual executions and Bailey’s shoe size didn’t match the murderer’s footprints.

Defence counsel Pickering told the court his client had “made a damning admission”. The police investigation was more Clouseau than Columbo with lies, contradictions and unsubstantiated claims.

And the prosecution and defence barristers, both QCs, made basic errors in their advocacy. The book makes clear that the miscarriages of justice in the case and subsequent developments have left a dreadful, indelible stain on the South Australian Government and its justice system.

The Sundown Murders Scandal: You Be the Jury by Steve Bishop. Available on Amazon as a paperback and ebook.

Steve Bishop was a senior writer and reporter on Queensland’s Sunday Sun from 1982 to 1989, covering the seminal Fitzgerald Inquiry and later writing a master’s thesis on newspapers’ failure to expose the state’s endemic corruption. He has lived in Brisbane for more than 40 years, is grateful to his wife Kaye for tolerating him for more than 50 years, travels widely and enjoys the qualities of red wine.

Want to see more stories from InDaily SA in your Google search results?

  1. Click here to set InDaily SA as a preferred source.
  2. Tick the box next to "InDaily SA". That's it.

Free to share

This article may be shared online or in print under a Creative Commons licence