Two protesters – one who feared losing his house after taking the state government to court over the North Adelaide Golf Course redevelopment – are facing a hefty bill.

Park lands protesters Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera have been ordered to pay $150,000 in costs after losing their federal court bid to halt the felling of 585 trees for the North Adelaide Golf Course redevelopment.
Federal Court Judge Natalie Charlesworth handed down the ruling on Thursday morning, after dismissing the case last month. She said tree felling and buildings rising on the park lands did not disturb the landscape “in a way that is likely to constitute a significant impact”.
The state government was seeking costs up to $550,000 to cover the total legal bill after initially offering Kemp Attrill and Milera a $150,000 settlement, which was not accepted before deadline.
Kemp Attrill said this morning’s outcome was “not the ultimate outcome that we wanted” as the duo had been pushing for no costs.
“This case has always been about accountability, and we have to be accountable to our actions as well. We respect the decision of the judge,” Kemp Attrill said.
“The fact that we’re not ordered to pay what the government has requested really shows the public interest, and I’m incredibly relieved that the judge was able to recognise the public interest in this case.
“It has taken a personal toll on us, but we’re very proud to have done it. This is a compromise, but it really shows that there is significant public interest in this case, and significant public interest in protecting the park lands.”
Kemp Attrill previously said a government application for costs would “bankrupt” them saying he feared losing his house to pay the bill.
He said on Thursday morning the total amount would likely be around $170,000 to cover all legal fees and expenses. Currently, $132,121 has been raised by members of the public on GoFundme to cover the duo’s legal fees.
Judge Charlesworth told the court she was “satisfied the litigation served a public interest in clarifying the meaning of the National Heritage Values as they apply to the Adelaide Park Lands”, which Kemp Attrill characterised as a win.
But state government spokesperson Nick Champion said “it’s a strange sort of a win”.
“All of this could have been avoided in court because these costs are the exact and reasonable offer that the government made. We made a reasonable offer around costs in order to protect taxpayers,” Champion said.
“We’re not trying to deter people from taking legal action. People have got a right to take legal action. What the government’s got to do is protect the taxpayers’ interests.”
SA Greens leader Robert Simms said it was an “appalling outcome for two South Australians who have shown extraordinary courage in standing up for our park lands”.
“The Malinauskas Government has been notoriously secretive about its plans for the Park Lands. When governments refuse to provide answers, it’s hardly surprising that community members turn to the courts,” Simms said.
“I think it sets a terrible precedent for anyone considering taking legal action to protect our environment. People shouldn’t have to risk their financial futures to hold their government to account.”
Want to see more stories from InDaily SA in your Google search results?