SA homebuyers are battling distorted pricing guides, SA Parliament heard today. One property boss says purchasers are “wasting money” on properties they have “no chance” of buying.

About two in three homes at Australian auctions are sold outside the price guide, SA parliament heard on Wednesday morning as the Australian Property Institute laid bare the “substantial problem” of over or under-valued listings.
Australian Property Institute Policy and Standards General Manager Harriet Warr told parliament it arrived at the figure after examining the “guide gap” in Victoria ahead of its state election this month – but it was a problem plaguing all Australians.
“The evidence quite clearly highlighted that there is a problem with agents guiding outside the price, both above and below it, and it often depends on the type of sale, be it private sale or auction,” she said.
Under-pricing was “particularly prevalent” at auctions, and an “enticing marketing mechanism” for agents and sellers, she told Parliament’s Select Committee on the Conduct of Real Estate Professionals today.
Underquoting is one of the tactics the committee was established to investigate, along with misleading or deceptive conduct impacting property vendors, purchasers and renters.
“More often than not, [under-pricing] is to get people through the front door who otherwise wouldn’t even consider that property, and it’s to generate interest and generate that idea of a fear of missing out,” Warr said.
“There is that FOMO aspect to it, but you do see people wasting money on building and pest reports, wasting money on lawyer fees, wasting a lot of time.
“But also missed opportunities in attending property inspections or auctions that they would otherwise go for in order to attend something that they often had no chance of actually winning the property in the first place.”
Her evidence comes as New South Wales and Victoria are reforming price-guide rules, and Greens leader Robert Simms, who chairs the real estate inquiry, said SA could follow suit.
“We have heard concerns of warped price guides. One suggestion that was put to the committee was mandating independent valuation of a property to ensure transparency,” Simms said.
“The committee is not yet at the stage of considering recommendations as it is still hearing evidence, but as Chair, I have an open mind to reform in this area.”
Each state currently has different pricing laws, but the Australian Property Institute is calling for tighter evidence and transparency rules across state lines, saying SA laws regulate how prices are advertised, but “say much less” about how the price is set.
“South Australia’s framework is sound in principle; the agent must give a genuine estimate, must give the vendor the comparable sales that support it, and can’t advertise below a prescribed minimum,” Warr said.
Warr said the gaps in SA’s current laws mean that when agents set prices, there is no criteria for how many similar sales they’re using as a guide, how recent those sales were or if they were in the same property area.
The Australian Property Institute recommended minimum standards be set in each of these areas, and agents should have to keep evidence of how they set prices for five years.
They also recommend that an agent should not be able to advertise a price that is lower than what the seller has already rejected or below a passed-in bid.
Buyers should be provided with “the agent’s estimate, the comparable sales it relies on, and any independent valuation obtained for the property”, similar to the new laws in Victoria and New South Wales, Warr said.
Today’s evidence comes after the committee also heard stories of rogue tenants and “meth lab” fears, calls for bonds to be scrapped and an under-resourced and overrun complaints hotline.
The committee is expected to hand down a report of recommendations to parliament in 2027.
Want to see more stories from InDaily SA in your Google search results?