‘Improper, disparaging’: The council feud costing ratepayers thousands

Investigations into a northern suburbs councillor have now cost ratepayers almost $50,000, with a new report into altercations adding to the growing bill.

Nov 17, 2026, updated Nov 17, 2026
Yassir Ajrish has been the subject of two investigations into alleged behavioural standards breaches. Photo: Facebook.
Yassir Ajrish has been the subject of two investigations into alleged behavioural standards breaches. Photo: Facebook.

Campbelltown Councillor and Mayoral candidate Yassir Ajrish should apologise to Mayor Jill Whittaker and undertake social media training with a “suitably qualified expert” after breaching three social media behavioural standards, a new report reveals.

The latest report comes just two weeks after a separate investigation, that cost ratepayers $30,000, found Ajrish had breached multiple behavioural standards in a heated exchange with Whittaker’s husband Robert Brennan while engaging in unauthorised campaigning at a citizenship ceremony.

A new, lengthy 112-page investigation from Kelledy Jones Lawyers, that was authored by Michael Kelledy on November 5, cost ratepayers a further $18,000.

This report alleged that Ajrish made “improper, disparaging and potentially defamatory posts on the Facebook Page” concerning Mayor Jill Whittaker. The posts include mentions of Whittaker’s breaches of the Local Government Association’s bullying and harassment standards from 2023, and that she ran unopposed in the 2022 election.

Kelledy found Ajrish had breached three behavioural standards clauses and “the volume, tone and framing of the posts moved beyond ordinary political discourse, targeting the Mayor personally and repeatedly”.

“In particular, the posts appear to target Mayor Whittaker personally and repeatedly, and to invite public criticism of her integrity and performance in a way that is not merely incidental to debate about council business or issues of the Campbelltown area,” Kelledy said.

“The language and presentation of the posts are, objectively, capable of undermining public confidence in Mayor Whittaker and, by extension, in the council.”

But Ajrish, who is running for Mayor in the next council elections, has repeatedly denied allegations of wrongdoing and was “willing to provide a detailed response once the allegations have been sufficiently particularised”.

“I will no longer engage substantively with, or provide responses to, complaints where reasonable requests for the information necessary to understand and respond to the allegations continue to be ignored,” Ajrish said.

Stay informed, daily

“On a number of occasions, I have sought further information, context and supporting material concerning allegations put to me. Those requests have either not been adequately answered or the material provided has consisted of selected, redacted or isolated screenshots and extracts.”

A member of the public also made five complaints regarding private messages from the ‘Cr Yassir AJ Ajrish – For Mayor – Campbelltown Council’ Facebook page, which has been repeatedly targeted with racist comments since the start of this year.

One message directed to a member of the community said: “would love to see you out in public while campaigning… I’ll teach you a lesson about pathetic attitudes in Campbelltown City Council”.

Another message said “lay one finger on Yassir and you won’t be happy. We promise you that”.

Kelledy found that while the messages did not breach behavioural standards, “the tone and content of the messages sent from the Facebook Page were inconsistent with the standard of respectful, reasonable and responsible communication expected of an elected member”.

Ajrish said “a screenshot, particularly where it has been cropped, redacted or removed from the surrounding conversation, does not by itself establish the complete factual circumstances of an allegation”.

The councillor has been ordered to make a public apology to Whittaker at a council meeting within one month and has been required to undertake social media training.

Want to see more stories from InDaily SA in your Google search results?

  1. Click here to set InDaily SA as a preferred source.
  2. Tick the box next to "InDaily SA". That's it.
News